ChefBook
A substitution is a trade. You are swapping one ingredient’s job — acidity, fat, structure, thickening, lift — for something else that does most of that job. The swaps below are the ones that hold up in ordinary home cooking, with the ratio and, more usefully, the situation where each one lets you down.
The quick table
| Missing | Use instead (per amount in the recipe) | Works for | Fails when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buttermilk, 1 cup | 1 cup milk + 1 tbsp lemon juice or white vinegar, left 5–10 minutes | Pancakes, scones, soda bread, marinades | You need the thickness — thinned plain yogurt is closer |
| Heavy cream (cooking), 1 cup | ¾ cup milk + ¼ cup melted butter | Soups, pan sauces, mashed potatoes | You need to whip it — it will never hold peaks |
| Egg (baking), 1 | 1 tbsp ground flaxseed + 3 tbsp water, rested 5 minutes; or ¼ cup unsweetened applesauce or mashed banana | Muffins, brownies, quick breads, cookies | Eggs are the structure — sponge cake, soufflé, meringue, custard — or the recipe uses more than 2 |
| Cornstarch (thickening), 1 tbsp | 2 tbsp all-purpose flour | Gravy, stews, pie fillings | You want a clear, glossy sauce — flour turns it opaque and needs a few minutes of simmering to lose its raw taste |
| Baking powder, 1 tsp | ¼ tsp baking soda + ½ tsp cream of tartar | Any batter you bake right away | The batter has to wait — this mix starts working as soon as it gets wet |
| Self-rising flour, 1 cup | 1 cup all-purpose flour + 1½ tsp baking powder + ¼ tsp salt | Scones, biscuits, simple cakes | The recipe also adds its own leavener — check you are not doubling up |
| Sour cream, 1 cup | 1 cup plain Greek yogurt | Dips, toppings, baking | It goes into a boiling sauce — yogurt splits, so stir it in off the heat |
| Feta | Ricotta salata (closest), or crumbled goat cheese | Salads, pastries, baked dishes | You need it to hold cubes — goat cheese is softer and less salty |
| Wine (in cooking), 1 cup | 1 cup stock + about 1 tsp vinegar or lemon juice | Braises, risotto, pan sauces | The wine is the point of the dish — coq au vin is not coq au stock |
| Brown sugar, 1 cup | 1 cup granulated sugar + 1 tbsp molasses (2 tbsp for dark brown) | Cookies, sauces, glazes | You have no molasses — plain white sugar works but cookies spread more and taste flatter |
How to tell if a substitution will work
Before you swap, ask what the missing ingredient is doing in this recipe. The same ingredient can do different jobs in different dishes:
- Eggs bind a meatball, lift a cake, set a custard and emulsify mayonnaise. A flax egg binds; it does not lift or set. That is why it is fine in brownies and hopeless in a sponge.
- Buttermilk adds acidity, which reacts with baking soda to make bubbles. If the recipe uses baking soda, whatever you substitute must also be acidic — that is why plain milk on its own gives flat pancakes.
- Cream adds fat. Fat carries flavour and stops sauces from splitting. Milk alone is too lean; the butter puts the fat back.
- Cornstarch thickens at a lower temperature and gives a clear finish. Flour thickens too, but more slowly and cloudily.
If the ingredient is doing one simple job, almost anything that does that job will work. If it is doing three jobs at once, look for a different recipe.
Swaps that rarely work
Some substitutions get repeated online but disappoint in practice:
- Baking soda for baking powder, one for one. Baking soda is roughly three to four times stronger and needs an acid. Used straight, it makes food taste soapy and metallic.
- Oil for butter in pastry. Pastry relies on solid fat making layers. Oil gives you something closer to a cracker.
- Skim milk for cream in anything that boils. It curdles more easily and never thickens.
- More than two egg replacements in one bake. Each swap moves the result a bit further from the original; stack enough of them and you are baking a different recipe.
Measuring substitutes accurately
Substitutions are where small measuring errors add up. Two habits help:
- Weigh when you can. A cup of flour can be anywhere from about 110 g to over 140 g depending on how it was scooped; King Arthur Baking’s ingredient weight chart uses 120 g. If you are swapping 2 tablespoons of flour for 1 of cornstarch, the difference barely matters. If you are rebuilding self-rising flour for a whole cake, it does.
- Swap one thing at a time. If the result goes wrong, you will know why.
If the recipe is in grams and your substitution ratios are in cups (or the other way round), see how to convert a European recipe to American measurements.
Asking about a specific recipe
General tables cover the common cases. The awkward ones — “can I use crème fraîche instead of mascarpone in this tiramisu?” — depend on the rest of the recipe.
In ChefBook, Ask Chef answers that kind of question with the recipe already in context, so it knows the other ingredients, the quantities and the method. Ask Chef is a Premium feature; free accounts get 5 uses of Premium features a week.
If the problem is a whole missing shopping list rather than one ingredient, flip the question round: find recipes that fit what you already have. The What Should I Cook wizard is free and ranks recipes by how many of your ingredients they use.
Questions people ask
Can I use milk instead of buttermilk?
Not on its own if the recipe uses baking soda — add 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar per cup and leave it for 5–10 minutes first. In a recipe leavened only with baking powder, plain milk works, though the result is a little less tangy.
What is the best egg substitute for baking?
For one egg in muffins, brownies or quick breads, a flax egg (1 tbsp ground flaxseed + 3 tbsp water) is the most reliable. For a moister, sweeter bake, ¼ cup of applesauce or mashed banana. Neither replaces eggs in sponges, meringues or custards.
Can I substitute flour for cornstarch?
Yes, as a thickener: use twice as much flour as cornstarch and simmer for a few minutes so it loses its raw taste. Expect a cloudier sauce.
Does a substitution change the calories?
Usually a little, sometimes a lot — swapping cream for milk and butter barely moves it; swapping sour cream for Greek yogurt cuts it noticeably. If you track it, calculate the calories per serving after the swap, not before.
Keep every recipe in one place
ChefBook is free on the App Store and Google Play — save your first recipe today.
phone camera